recreational mathematics - How fast are a ruler and compass?

Edit on July 31: Now the upper bound is tight (up to replacing n by O(n)). The improvement over the older version is in the argument after Lemma 1. Now we consider the Weil absolute logarithmic height of an algebraic number instead of the length.

Here is a proof that D(n) < 2^2cn for some positive constant c>0 for sufficiently large n. In other words, the answer to the “can one do better” part of the question 2 is negative.

As Terry Tao pointed out, this problem can be rephrased in the algebraic form. We have z₀=0 and z₁=1, and any z_n (n≥2) can be obtained from earlier numbers by addition, subtraction, multiplication, division or square root. The claim follows if |z_n| < 2^2O(n).

Lemma 1: The degree of z_n over ℚ is at most 2ⁿ.

Proof: Let F_n=ℚ(z₀, …, z_n) be the minimum field containing ℚ∪{z₀, …, z_n}. Then F₀=ℚ, and F_n is either equal to F_n−1 or an extension of F_n−1 obtained by adjoining a square root. Since adjoining a square root of a non-square element gives an extension of degree 2, the extension degree [F_n:F_n−1] is either 1 or 2. By the degree formula, it holds that [F_n:ℚ] = [F_n:F₀] = [F_n:F_n−1][F_n−1:F_n−2]…[F₁:F₀] ≤ 2ⁿ. Therefore, the degree of every element in F_n over ℚ is also at most 2ⁿ. (end of proof of Lemma 1)

There is a function called the Weil absolute logarithmic height h(α) defined on algebraic numbers α which takes nonnegative real values. See Section 3.2 of [Wal00] for its definition and the proof of the following properties:

1. If α is an algebraic number of degree d, then |α| ≤ exp(dh(α)).


2. If p and q are integers which are relatively prime, then h(p/q) = ln max{|p|,|q|}.


3. If α and β are algebraic numbers, then h(α+β) ≤ h(α) + h(β) + ln 2.


4. If α and β are algebraic numbers, then h(αβ) ≤ h(α) + h(β).


5. If α is an algebraic number and n is an integer, then h(αⁿ) = |n|h(α). In particular, h(√α)=h(α)/2.

By using the properties 2–5 and the mathematical induction, we can prove that h(z_n) ≤ 2ⁿ ln 2. By combining the property 1 and Lemma 1, we obtain that |z_n| ≤ 2²²ⁿ.

References

[Wal00] Michel Waldschmidt: Diophantine Approximation on Linear Algebraic Groups: Transcendence Properties of the Exponential Function in Several Variables, Springer, 2000.