arithmetic topology - Zeta function for curves in a manifold

Motivation

In the analogy between prime numbers and knots, the prime number is thought sometimes as the circle of length $l([p]) = text{log},p$. This is so you can express the zeta function as
$$ zeta(s) = sum_{Dge0} e^{-l(D)s}$$

where the sum goes over effective divisors on $text{Spec},mathbb Z$ and length is extended there by additivity. Similarly, you can do it to rewrite Dedekind zeta function for other number fields.

Question

I wonder, what is the right analogue of above formula for a manifold with metric? Perhaps:

1. integration over all closed curves of the expression $e^{-l(D)s}$


2. summation over positive sums of classes of closed geodesics.

I think I've heard something about definition 2, but I suspect if the two above are defined correctly they will be the same. Is it possible to formalize this definition? Do different formalizations lead to the same zeta-function?

Updates

Yes, I think this should be related to Laplacians, Selberg trace formula and dynamical system zetas. What I said I've heard about definition 2 was probably the Selberg zeta, but I can't say it clearly, hence questions.