Thursday, 2 June 2016

grammaticality - What part of speech is "unless" in the following sentence?

In the sentence,




Unless disciplined, a dog becomes a household pest




unless is a conjunction*. This sentence is really a reduction of




Unless it is disciplined, a dog becomes a household pest.




The conjunctional function becomes clearer upon a rearrangement of the clauses:




A dog becomes a household pest, unless [it is] disciplined.




The most likely constructions a native speaker would use are the following:




  • A dog becomes a household pest, unless it is disciplined.

  • Unless it is disciplined, a dog becomes a household pest.

  • Unless a dog is disciplined, it becomes a household pest.

  • Unless disciplined, a dog becomes a household pest.




*I see how unless could be said to be used as a preposition:




A dog becomes a household pest unless disciplined.




(No comma before unless and disciplined becomes an adjective.) I doubt this is formal usage, though. Before the independent clause, however, I would always take unless as a conjunction.

No comments:

Post a Comment